The Holocaust: Divine Retribution?

Nathan Lopes Cardozo

vrijdag 9 juni 2017

For some years now, there has been a major debate among religious thinkers over whether the Holocaust should be seen as divine punishment. Pointing to the Torah's warnings that divine curses would come true if widespread violations of the Torah’s laws were committed (1), some thinkers maintain that the Holocaust is clearly the result of the Jewish people’s transgressions.

After looking into these verses and reading their midrashic comments, it would indeed be difficult to deny the marked similarity between the Torah’s predictions and what happened during the Holocaust.

Nevertheless, this position could be challenged and is, in fact, dangerous.

Rabbi Avraham Yeshaya Karelitz, z“l, one of the greatest halachic authorities of our generation – and popularly known by the name of his multi-volume magnum opus of Talmudic halachic works, Chazon Ish – discusses the problem of heresy and deliberate violation of Jewish law, and its halachic consequences in today's society.

In the old days, people guilty of holding heretical views, or deliberately violating Torah law, were penalized and prohibited from joining some of the community's religious ceremonies and fulfilling certain religious functions. Today, however, according to Rabbi Karelitz z”l, such halachic rulings can no longer be applied without great hesitation:

"[Such laws] only applied at times when the divine presence was clearly revealed, such as in the days when there were open miracles and a heavenly voice was heard and when the righteous would operate under direct divine intervention, which could be observed by anybody. Then, the heretics were of a special deviousness, bending their evil inclination toward immoral desires and licentiousness. In such days, there was [the need] to remove this kind of wickedness from the world, since everybody knew that it would bring divine retribution to the world [including] drought, pestilence and famine. But at the time of "divine hiding", in which faith has become weak in people, there is no purpose in taking such action [harsh measurements against heretics and violators]; in fact, it has the reverse effect and will only increase their lawlessness and be viewed as coercion and violence [by religious fanatics]. And therefore we have an obligation to try to bring them back with “cords of love” (2) (3)”.

This unprecedented statement, made by a major ultra-Orthodox authority, is, we believe, of great importance. The Chazon Ish maintains that we cannot compare earlier (certainly not biblical) periods with our own days. In former times, faith was strong and people didn’t doubt its foundations. Divine intervention was clear, so there was no reason for anyone to doubt God's existence and the truth of His will as stated in the Torah. Therefore, heresy and violation of the Torah's precepts could only be the result of deliberate rebellion. People knew that they were violating the words of the living God, since there was no doubt concerning His existence and will. Thus, there were legitimate reasons to take action against those who broke the covenant and spoke heretically. They knew that they were falsifying the truth. It was purely their earthly desires that made them travel down that road.

This, however, is no longer the case. God's presence is not manifest as it once was, and much of what happens to humankind seems to be random, with no indication that it is the work of the Lord of the Universe. Therefore, one can no longer call heretical views the result of deliberate viciousness. These views may, in fact, be the honest consequence of careful deliberation that is clouded by confusion; by not knowing how to view and understand the workings of history, and events such as personal tragedy.

For several centuries, so-called ‘academic studies’ of the Torah have undermined its authenticity, convincing a great number of well-meaning people of ‘proof’ that the Torah does not reflect God’s will. Therefore, there was no reason to live by its precepts.

This is no longer deliberate heresy. It could rather be called intellectual perplexity.

As such, it is difficult to argue that the Holocaust was caused by divine anger for the violations of Torah precepts and deliberate heresy. The curses in the Torah are meant to come down on those who, against better judgment, and with the full understanding that they are violating God’s will, decide to do so; but not on those who are confused by or are the victims of others' misunderstandings. This, I believe, is the implication of the words written by Rabbi Avraham Yeshaya Karelitz, z“l, in relation to the question of whether the Holocaust should be seen as divine retribution.

Whatever the religious meaning of the Holocaust may or may not be, it is clear that it cannot be seen in terms of divine retribution.


(1) Vayikra 26: 14-43; Devarim 28: 15-69.

(2) Hoshea 11:4.

(3) Chazon Ish, Yoreh Deah, Hilchot Shechita 2:16.

3 + 3 = ?

Columns 2020

Columns 2019

Columns 2018

Columns 2017

Columns 2016

Columns 2015

Columns 2014

Columns 2013

Doneren

Crescas kan niet zonder jouw steun. Met elke donatie, hoe klein ook, steun je onze activiteiten en zorg je dat wij nog meer voor Joods Nederland kunnen betekenen.